The Capacity Market Clearing Price is the massive, controversial safety net of the modern power grid. As cheap wind and solar flood the energy market, they drive the price of electricity to $0, bankrupting the dispatchable gas and nuclear plants needed when the sun sets. The Capacity Market solves this 'Missing Money' problem by paying these plants billions of dollars simply to exist and promise to turn on during a winter crisis, regardless of whether they actually generate a single electron.
In an 'Energy-Only' market (like Texas ERCOT), plants are only paid when they physically inject MWhs into the grid. If a gas peaker plant only runs 5 days a year during a heatwave, it must charge $10,000/MWh to survive. A Capacity Market (like PJM in the US or the UK grid) splits the revenue stream. Every year, the grid operator runs a massive auction asking: 'Who can guarantee they will be available 3 years from now?' Generators bid their fixed O&M costs (in $/MW-day). The grid operator accepts the cheapest bids until they have secured enough MWs to survive a 1-in-10-year blizzard. The last, most expensive bid accepted sets the 'Clearing Price', and every winning plant is paid that price just for remaining operational.
Resource Adequacy Modeling
Grid engineers run stochastic weather models to determine the absolute maximum Peak Load expected in 3 years (e.g., 150 GW).
The Forward Auction
Power plants submit sealed bids. A nuclear plant bids low ($50/MW-day) because it runs constantly. A decrepit coal plant bids high ($200/MW-day) because it needs the cash to survive.
Clearing the Market
The operator stacks the bids from cheapest to most expensive until they hit 150 GW. The 150th GW sets the clearing price, which is paid to all winners.
- Over-procurement: Grid operators are concerned of blackouts, so they routinely buy vastly more capacity than mathematically necessary, wasting billions of taxpayer dollars.
- Performance Risk: During Winter Storm Elliott in the US, gas plants that had received millions in capacity payments literally froze and failed to turn on, proving the market design was deeply flawed.